Ask These Unique Interview Questions To Find Your Next Great Sales Rep

There’s no perfect system that can guarantee you’ll hire the right person every time. But there are fundamental guidelines you must follow if you expect to recruit your way to the top. Try asking these 8 interview questions for hiring superstar sales reps.

Recruit, Train, and Motivate

Essentially, a sales manager’s primary responsibility is to recruit, train and motivate his or her sales force to achieve peak performance. Of these three vitally important management tasks, recruiting is the least understood, and by far the most challenging.

If you’re successful during the recruiting interview process and hire a superstar sales rep, you’ll find that he or she is self-motivated, coachable, and eager to train.

On the other hand, if you’re recruiting out of desperation because your sales reps are failing left and right and you need another warm body, you’ll experience low morale, continued high turnover, and find yourself constantly in training mode.

Are You a Buyer or a Seller?

It pays to be patient and selective during the interviewing process. Obviously, during the recruiting process, what you’re looking for is a hard-working, self-motivated, team player, so it pays to be selective and have high standards.

Approach Interviews With A Buyer’s Mentality

By approaching the interviewing process with a buyer’s mentality, you’re more likely to maintain your objectivity and hire a top producer.

An unsuccessful sales manager sees his or her role during the interviewing process as that of a “seller” rather than a “buyer” and as a result, they have a tendency to over-emphasize the compensation potential and understate the inherent challenges associated with a sales career.

If you talk more than you listen during an interview, chances are you’re a seller and not a buyer.

A manager who goes into the interview with a “buyer’s” mentality understands the importance and responsibility of being straightforward and laying all the cards on the table.

They know through experience that it’s better to run the risk of scaring off a prospective new hire than to face a disillusioned sales rep once they have been brought onboard.

First Impressions Are Lasting Impressions

When it comes to making a favorable first impression, little things make a big difference.

Did the candidate arrive on time for the interview and was he or she well groomed and dressed appropriately? Did the candidate sit up straight, smile frequently, and maintain good eye contact throughout the interview? Were they talking too much or too little? Would you want this person working in your office or for one of your competitors?

You would be fooling yourself not to anticipate that your prospective new hire has been coached for a standard office interview.

Success and Failure Leave a Trail

Both success and failure leave a trail. So it’s important to ask open-ended questions to uncover the candidate’s past experiences where he or she has faced difficulties and demonstrated the resiliency to bounce back.

This question lends itself to a valuable discussion about the necessity of self-motivation and maintaining a positive attitude in the sales profession.

Why Spousal Support Matters

As a sales manager, if the candidate impressed me during the initial interview, I invited the candidate and his or her spouse out to dinner.

When you’re interviewing a salesperson for a commission-based position, it’s imperative to check for spousal support.

I believe that strong spousal support is the most important factor in predicting a sales rep’s success. If the candidate’s spouse is not fully supportive, the smart play is to terminate the hiring process immediately.

8 Of the Best Interview Questions For Hiring Superstar Sales Reps

Do you have written goals you want to accomplish and if so, tell me about them?

With this question, you’re looking for indications of the candidate’s maturity, focus, planning ability, and desire for achievement. It’s rare to have a candidate bring his or her written goals to the interview.

How did you earn your first paycheck, how old were you, and what did you do with the money?

With this question you’re probing to check the candidate’s work ethic.

What are the top three leadership traits that you look for in a manager?

With this question you’re attempting to gauge the candidate’s expectation of you and ascertain his or her preferred management style.

Have you ever failed at something. If so, why did you fail and what did you learn from the experience?

This question lends itself to a discussion on resiliency, personal responsibility, and tendencies under pressure.

Why do you believe that you are going to be successful as a sales rep?

This question gives a candidate the opportunity to convince you that he or she has what it takes to be a top producer in your organization. If the candidate can’t sell themselves to you, don’t waste your time brining them onboard.

What is the one thing you would improve about yourself?

This question gives you an indication of a candidate’s self-image.

Other than family members, who has been the greatest influence in your life and why?

If I hired you and you failed as a sales rep, what do you think the main reason would be?

This is also a great question to ask the candidate’s spouse.

The Two Must-Have Qualities Of Any New Hire

In my opinion, there are two mandatory qualities any new hire must possess.


The first quality I look for is loyalty. If a sales rep is not loyal to his or her company, they are more likely to violate company policies and procedures. Disloyal employees are also the first to leave when the going gets tough.


The second quality I look for is dependability. It makes absolutely no sense to invest huge amounts of your time and emotional capital training someone that you can’t depend on.

A sales manager is only as good as his or her candidate pipeline.

While some turnover in your sales force such as retirement, promotion, and transfer is understandable and can be anticipated; the quitter is often unpredictable. With this in mind, we must think of recruiting as a long-term strategy rather than a short-term knee-jerk reaction.

Do Not Underestimate Personnel Turnover

Perhaps the greatest mistake a sales manager can make is underestimating his or her personnel turnover. If your personnel turnover is high, it’s more than likely caused by improper recruiting, rather than inadequate training, or a lack of incentives.

Even if you’re the world’s best trainer and motivator, if you haven’t recruited correctly you’ll experience high turnover.

Refilling Your Recruiting Pipeline With Quality Candidates

If your recruiting pipeline has dried up, here are some time-tested tips that will assist you in filling it back up with quality salespeople!

  • Keep your sales team informed on the status of your recruiting efforts by focusing on recruiting as an agenda item at every office meeting.
  • Design and implement an incentive program for your sales force that places an emphasis on recruiting.
  • To have an effective recruiting program, your sales team needs to get enthusiastically involved in the recruiting process. Let them know that their ability to recruit new candidates is considered a vital leadership skill for development. Their assistance is essential to the health of the organization.

I hope this information has inspired to look at your recruiting program with fresh eyes and a renewed determination to recruit your way to the top!

Looking for tips on how to build a high performing sales team? Our 25-page eBook, The Sales Manager’s Ultimate Interview Guide teaches you exactly how to conduct more effective sales interviews and more interview questions for hiring sales rockstars.

About the author

John Boe

John Boe is an entertaining speaker with a powerful message and a passion to…

Online Courses

Learn anywhere, any time, on any device.


Learn Online

Self-paced courses from the
world's top sales experts

Virtual Training

Live, interactive instruction in small
groups with master trainers


One-to-one personalized coaching
focused on your unique situation